Problems
Troubleshooting: when something goes wrong with digitised coins
Even a simple inventory throws up puzzles from time to time. A photo comes out with a white spot where the portrait should be, image search suggests an entirely different country, two catalogues describe the coin differently, and the inventory file suddenly vanishes from your computer. A separate group of problems comes with buying: the seller is rushing you, and the coin seems like too lucky a find. Below are six common situations and calm steps that help in each of them.
If you cannot identify a coin today, write down everything you can see and come back to it in a week.
How this section works: first short answers to common questions, then a step-by-step routine for when a coin simply will not identify.
Common situations
Glare and white spots in photos
Glare comes from direct light and the flash. Turn off the flash, move the lamp to the side and cover it with tracing paper or plain paper, and put a white sheet on the other side as a reflector. Tilt the light source slightly, not the phone.
I cannot identify a coin
Copy all the inscriptions letter for letter, even the ones you do not understand, and describe the design on each side separately. First find the country by the language and coat of arms, then the denomination, and only then the year. Use photo search as a hint.
Catalogues give different information
Catalogues are compiled by different people, and every one of them has typos. Note both versions in your inventory along with the source of each, then look for a third independent source. What you can see on the coin itself has the final say.
My inventory is lost
Check your computer's recycle bin, the file's version history in cloud storage and the attachments in your email. If there are no copies, start again with the coins in albums: the numbers on the holders will help you restore order faster.
A seller is pushing for prepayment
Pressure is a favourite scammer tactic: "only one left", "someone else is taking it tomorrow". An honest seller will wait while you calmly check their history and ask for more photos. If the seller keeps pushing, it is better to walk away from the deal.
A coin looks "too good" for the deal
If a coin with an unusual date is offered easily and quickly, be cautious. Signs of a replica in general terms: blurry lettering, the wrong metal colour, seams on the edge, differences from catalogue photos. Ask for a photo of the edge and a shot of the coin on scales.
If you cannot identify a coin
Take good photos
Photograph both sides and the edge in diffused light, without glare. Many inscriptions can only be read on an enlarged photo, not with the naked eye.
Write down everything you see
Record the inscriptions exactly as they appear, including unfamiliar letters. Describe the images separately: coat of arms, portrait, plant, building, animal.
Work out the country
The language of the inscription, the alphabet and the coat of arms most often point to the country. If the alphabet is unfamiliar, compare it with alphabet tables in reference books.
Narrow down by denomination and year
In the online catalogue choose the country, then the denomination and the year. If the date uses a different calendar, that is a clue too: note it in your inventory.
Try photo search
Upload a sharp photo of one side with the background cropped out. Check the results against the inscriptions on the coin: a similar design does not mean the same coin.
Set it aside and come back
Add the coin to your inventory marked "not identified" together with everything you have found out. A fresh look a week later or a question to an experienced collector often solves the puzzle.
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step guides: a coin record card, phone photography, catalogue searches, swaps by post and digitising a collection in a weekend. Plus our article catalogue.
- Tools
What you need for record keeping: a phone or magnifier, diffused light, a spreadsheet, gloves and a soft mat, online catalogues and a backup of your inventory.
- Security
Counterfeits and replicas, prepayment to strangers, loud "we buy coins" ads, traps posing as catalogues and oversharing about your collection.
- Glossary
Key collector terms in plain words: obverse, reverse, edge, denomination, mintage, mint mark, condition and patina.
Sources
- Editorial materials of this guide
This guide describes digital tools in general terms; the information was checked on the preparation date shown on each page. Phone apps and online catalogues change their menus and section names with updates. If the buttons and options on your screen are named differently, check the help pages of the program you use.